Kaziranga national park versus 1 union of india represented by the ministry of environment of forests. The supreme court yesterday issued notice to the central government on a plea by the cbi challenging the gauhati high court verdict holding the. Central bureau of investigation, popularly called cbi, is a. On november 6, 20 the gauhati high court had held that the 1963 resolution of the union government constituting the central bureau of investigation cbi is unconstitutional and that the cbi can be constituted only through a statute read order below. The central bureau of investigationcbi through the deputy inspector general, head of zone, shillong, for.
Gauhati high court rules cbi is unconstitutional india news. Attorney general g e vahanvati had told the court that the gauhati high courts reasoning that the dspe act was not applicable to the cbi was a convoluted logic. The gauhati high court has quashed the union home ministry resolution by which the central bureau of investigation was constituted way back in 1963. Sc stays gauhati high court order declaring cbi unconstitutional. Nov 09, 20 attorney general g e vahanvati had told the court that the gauhati high court s reasoning that the dspe act was not applicable to the cbi was a convoluted logic. The cbi, in a limbo since wednesdays gauhati high court verdict declared it unconstitutional and stripped it of all policing powers, was revived on saturday after the supreme court. The gauhati high court high court of assam, nagaland, mizoram and arunachal pradesh. Gauhati high court syllabus 2019 ghc lda syllabus, exam. A critique of two recent judgments of the gauhati high court by sri s. In the gauhati high court the high court of assam, nagaland, miozram, and arunachal pradesh pilsuo motu 662012, 672012, and wpc 64820 and 486020. The gauhati high court high court of assam, nagaland, mizoram and arunachal pradesh home. The gauhati high court was established on 1 march 1948 after the government of india act 1935 was passed. Neither the gauhati high court nor the national informatics centre, ministry of information technology, government of india is responsible for any consequences by use of such information.
May 26, 2016 the gauhati high court has quashed the union home ministry resolution by which the central bureau of investigation was constituted way back in 1963. The current chief justice of guwahati court is the honble shri ajit singh. A division bench of the gauhati high court has set aside a resolution that created the central bureau of investigation, indias premier investigation agency. In a relief to the centre,the supreme court on saturday stayed the november 6 judgment of the gauhati high court declaring the cbi as unconstitutional,observing that the accused in two sensational cases have sought stay of their trial on the basis of that judgment posting the matter for further hearing on december 6,the bench of chief justice of india p. Supreme court stays gauhati high courts order, saves cbi. The legal principles governing this field have been summedup as under. Interim orders and judgments are also available under the link case status on the home page. Supp 1 scc 180 and a judgement of the delhi high court, in. In a relief to the centre,the supreme court on saturday stayed the november 6 judgment of the gauhati high court declaring the cbi as unconstitutional,observing that the accused in two sensational cases have sought stay of their trial on the basis of that judgment.
In a major relief for the government, the supreme court today stayed the gauhati high court s unprecedented order declaring the central bureau of investigation or cbi as unconstitutional which. In our opinion, the scope and extent of powers of the high court under section 379 of the 1978 code is well defined and has been disclosed by the above referred judgment of the supreme court of india. The centre had moved the supreme court through the department of personnel and training dopt, which is the administrative ministry for the cbi, against the november 6 ruling of the gauhati high court that the the resolution number 43161t dated 141963 issued by secretary to the government of india, v. Nov 17, 2016 this would mean that the stay on the gauhati high court judgment would continue. However, the inquiry by the central bureau of investigation cbi under the direction of the gauhati high court brought out the truth and led to filing of the chargesheet against 7 seven army personnel in the court of special judicial magistrate, kamrup under section 302201 read with section 109 of the indian penal code, 1860 ipc in 2002. In a recent landmark judgment pdf, the constitution of cbi was held unconstitutional by gauhati high court. Gauhati high court had given a verdict on 6 november 20, that cbi is unconstitutional and does.
According to the accused, at the relevant time lici, morigaon used to. By way of this common judgment and order, i propose to. The present appeal has arisen out of the judgment and order, dated 30112007. With regard to the judicial inquiry and high court cases the gauhati high court had entertained writ petitions into allegations of the death of as. Supreme court stays gauhati high courts order that held cbi. The state of encounter killings in india united ngo. As against the order of the orissa high court, the state preferred an appeal. Administration of the gauhati high court directing the petitioner, who is a deputy registrar of the gauhati high court itanagar permanent bench, to show cause, under rule 23 of the gauhati high court services appointment, condition of service and conduct rules, 1967 for short, the rules, read with article 311 of the constitution.
Sri siba prasad rajbongshi, so late sonaram rajbongshi. Introduction the gauhati high court legal aid committee with its office at the gauhati high court principal seat came into being in the year 1987, constituted by the government of assam with the very purpose to assure and secure equal justice for all, specially to the weaker section of the society irrespective of caste, creed and race. Bethel high school, pangkhua approached this court by filing w. He was born on september 6, 1956, and began practising as a lawyer in october 1979, in the areas of civil, criminal and constitutional law of the high court of madhya pradesh, located in jabalpur. Mukherjee permanent judge for the state of mizoram. Gauhati high court terms cbis genesis unconstitutional the. His first job as a judge was in that same court, as additional judge in 2002, and as permanent judge. Sep 25, 2019 gauhati high court syllabus 2019 is available for the candidates who are searching for it. In a curious judgement, the gauhati hc has struck down the resolution through which cbi was set up and held all its actions as. Ext111, wherein it is alleged that racketeering activities are going on in respect of. Judgement and order with the help of this writ petition, made under article 226, the. Gauhati high court rules cbi is unconstitutional in a curious judgement, the gauhati high court has struck down the resolution through which the central bureau of investigation was set up and held all its actions as unconstitutional. In the context of the factual scenario, the honble supreme court reiterated the law. The immediate provocation for this essay is to attempt a better answer.
In the case of the supreme court all reported judgments which are published in scr journal, since its inception i. Central bureau of investigation, represented by its head of branch cbi, acb, betkuchi, p. Training institute n ejoti the theoretical and practical aspects of precedents is the staple of all training programmes in the north eastern judicial officers training institute. The division bench of gauhati high court has endorsed the views. Gauhati high court sets aside 1963 resolution on cbi. Even indian government was well aware of this dangerous situation and despite that it failed to remedy the situation. In our opinion, the consistent and well settled law on the point is that the high court can interfere with the order of acquittal only when. Union of india 199711scc312, has also been relied upon by the learned counsel to contend that direction should be issued by the court to ensure that the impugned seismic survey is. In the gauhati high court t he high court of assam, nagaland, meghalaya, manipur, tripura, mizoram and arunachal pradesh crl. The central bureau of investigation, represented by its director, having its office at cgo complex, lodhi road, new delhi. The judgments information system consists of the judgments of the supreme court of india and several high courts. Honble gauhati high court in 2004 3 glt 444 db held that criminal. Download the ghc judicial assistant syllabus pdf along with the exam pattern. Jun 26, 2012 central bureau of investigation of investigation, 2010 9 scc 368 the apex court has further amplified the contours of the courts as to when criminal charges can be framed and as to when an accused can be discharged.
Daily work done statement of judicial officers of assam. Judgment order, fairness of trial does not mean that the trial has to be fair to the. This is an appeal against the judgment and order, dated 3107 2009, passed, in special case no. In a curious judgement, the gauhati high court has struck down the resolution through which the central bureau of investigation was set up and held all its actions as unconstitutional. Gauhati high court syllabus 2019 is available for the candidates who are searching for it. Nov 09, 20 the centre had moved the supreme court through the department of personnel and training dopt, which is the administrative ministry for the cbi, against the november 6 ruling of the gauhati high court that the the resolution number 43161t dated 141963 issued by secretary to the government of india, v. The cbi appealed the verdict in delhi high court in 2000, and the court issued a warrant for the accused. Central bureau of investigation of investigation, 2010 9 scc 368 the apex court has further amplified the contours of the courts as to when criminal charges can be framed and as to when an accused can be discharged. Lalramzauva, the learned senior counsel that the case of the present petitioner is. Tithi ram rajbongshi, so late debiram rajbongshi, resident of village nakuchi, borgaon, p. The supreme court yesterday issued notice to the central government on a plea by the cbi challenging the gauhati high court verdict holding the agency unconstitutional after quashing the april 1.
The guwahati high court was promulgated by governor general of india on 1 march 1948 after the government of india act 1935 was passed. This would mean that the stay on the gauhati high court judgment would continue. It was originally known as the high court of assam and nagaland, but renamed as gauhati high court in 1971 by the north east areas reorganization act, 1971. Lalramzauva, the learned senior counsel that the case of the present petitioner is squarely covered by the judgment. The conference was attended by hon,ble the chief justice, gauhati high court, honble. The central bureau of investigation cbi is the premier investigating agency of india. The matter was heard by chief justice p sathasivam at his residence. The judgments reported in scr till 1993 also have headnotes. Supreme court issues notice to centre on cbi plea against. Delivering the judgment on wednesday a division bench of justice iqbal ahmed ansari and justice indira shah said, while we decline to hold and declare that the delhi special police establishment dspe act, 1946, is. Nov 10, 20 now cbi has been operating through an executive order. It was originally known as the high court of assam and nagaland, but renamed as gauhati high court in 1971 by the north east areas. However, the application for regular bail filed by the accused on 11th january, 2017 did advert to the statutory period for filing a charge sheet having.
Ajmal kasab mumbai 2611 attacker case judgement details. Gauhati high court declares cbi unconstitutional india news. Supreme court stays gauhati high courts order, saves. In case of any grievance relating to undue delay in judgement or. Check gauhati high court judicial asst exam syllabus, scheme of the examination, exam dates, timings, etc. The gauhati high court has struck down the resolution through which the central bureau investigation was set up and held all its actions as unconstitutional. The brief facts of the case, is that the central bureau of investigation cbi, guwahati, has suo motu registered a case bearing registration no. Supreme court stays gauhati high courts order that held. Guwahati high court guwahati court high court of guwahati. Pathak portfolio judge elevated as additional judge of the gauhati high court on 22 may 20. The tribunal also held that the cbi had also, after a detailed investigation, exonerated bamin tari and the closure report submitted by cbi on 28.
Supreme court reported in 1996 5 scc 287, indian council for enviro legal action v. According to the petitioner, during the course of the cbi court trial, he could discover that as per the provisions of section 14 of the nia act, 2008, there cannot be two parallel proceedings, one in the nia special court and the other in the cbi special court, having regard to the transaction in which the petitioner is said to be involved. Stay on gauhati hcs cbi judgment as sc dismisses interim. In a major relief for the government, the supreme court today stayed the gauhati high courts unprecedented order declaring the central bureau of investigation or cbi. Cbi found that his fathers name had appeared in the. Establishing the high court of assam with effect from 5 april 1948, for the then province of assam. The learned senior counsel also submitted that the division bench of the high court in the impugned judgment has proceeded on the basis as if the proviso civil appeal no. An answer was given but it appeared that the answer was not satisfactory. Filing form for cis in pdf formatin word format advocate database form for cis. On 5 july 1990, the aizawl permanent bench of the gauhati high court was established and inaugurated by the then chief justice of india, mr. The 1999 judgment noted that the influence of the father of the accused has been there.
Gauhati high court terms cbis genesis unconstitutional. Strictly speaking this is correct since the petitioner applied for regular bail on 11th january, 2017 in the gauhati high court he made no specific application for grant of default bail. The meeting discussed the judgment of honble supreme court in. Gauhati high court rules cbi is unconstitutional india.
1446 1501 1085 445 84 125 812 1366 257 1548 860 234 971 449 1241 441 1503 992 895 770 755 353 926 191 968 1302 889 1282 359 64 634 1456 109 459 453 1032 901 508 278 982 1021 1385